2023-09-26 Meeting notes - Joint OAM / NONRTRIC / SIM Community meeting

Time & Location:

Anti-Trust Notice

• Antitrust Policy Notice
• Antitrust Policy

Date

26 Sep 2023

Attendees

• John Keeney (Ericsson EST) (Ericsson EST & OSC NONRTRIC)
• Martin Skorupski (Highstreet & OSC OAM)
• Alex Stancu (Highstreet & OSC SIM)
• James Li (CMTI & OSC INT)
• N.K. Shankaranarayanan (ONAP)
• Ambrish Singh (Ericsson EST)
• Kevin Timoney (Ericsson EST)
• Rohith Rajneesh (Ericsson EST)
• Sonia Sangari (Ericsson EST)
• Denis G Noonan (Ericsson Software Technology) (Ericsson EST)
• RAVITEJA KARUMURI (EST) (Ericsson EST)
• Varadarajan (Samsung)
• May not have captured a full attendee list for this meeting  ... please add/remove yourself

See also / co-located (ONAP/O-RAN-SC/SMO - Meeting)

• Co-located with ONAP 2023-09-26 Meeting notes (ONAP/O-RAN-SC/SMO - Meeting)

Contents

Recording

• Recording (MP4 - lo res)

Notes:

Housekeeping:

• Martin Skorupski & Alex Stancu not available 03 Oct meeting.  (Public Holiday)
• Martin Skorupski  & Alex Stancu not available 10 Oct (Vacation)
  
• Martin Skorupski not available 17 Oct (Vacation) - & during F2F - Will cancel this occurrence
  

• Calendar:

  • https://lists.o-ran-sc.org/g/main/calendar

  • https://lists.onap.org/g/onap-meetings/calendar

  • 7am PDT | 10pm EDT | 14:00 UTC | 15:00 BST | 16:00 CEST | 17:00 EEST | 19:30 IST | 22:00 CST | 23:00 JST

• OSC SMO project calls now move to its own time slot - alternate Thursdays - TBC
  

  • See OSC RSAC Calendar: https://lf-o-ran-sc.atlassian.net/wiki/display/RSAC/calendars

  • See also OSC Meetings calendar: https://lists.o-ran-sc.org/g/main/calendar

  • (Note this meeting to open to anyone, including non-ORAN members)

  • We will maintain this slot for ONAP Alignment, and try flag issues/question to/from SMO meetings.

  • See OSC SMO Project meeting notes

• See also OSC AIML Project meeting notes

OSC Project roundup:

News from OSC TOC call last week

• https://lf-o-ran-sc.atlassian.net/wiki/display/TOC/#ORANSCTechnicalOversightCommittee(TOC)
  • Last week's TOC (Thursday):
    • OSC & OAI collaboration discussion continues.
      • Workshop https://openairinterface.org/joint-osc-oai-workshop-end-to-end-open-source-reference-designs-for-o-ran/ Northeastern University on the 14-15 November 2023
        
  • This week's TOC (in 2 days):
    • Looking for updates for different workstreams

NONRTRIC (John Keeney (Ericsson EST))

• Mostly same as last week:
  • Updating sonar scans and related updates to improve results: making good progress
  • Making good progress on rApp manager.
    
    • Demo 2 weeks ago:
      
      • 2023-09-12 Meeting notes - RApp Manager Interim Demo / Show&Tell Aravindhan Ayyanathan (Ericsson EST) 
    • Adding support for DME integration now. Will demo again in a few weeks.

  • OpenAPI-first in A1-PMS & ICS

    • Change from code→openapi→docs to openapi → code-stubs & docs

    • To better align with R1 specs as they mature

    • To improve expressiveness of docs etc.

    • Working now - tested functional equivalence achieved - merging this week. Then more work to follow.
      
  • Some changes in A1-Mediator in near-RT-RIC plt in H-Release.
    • Meeting planned with Near-RT-RIC team tomorrow.
    • Further investigation needed re effects on A1-PMS/ICS & A1-SIM
    • Looks like OSC_v2.1.0. A1-AP (P) profile will b deprecated
      • Will phase out support A1-SIM and A1-PMS in coming releases, when A1-Mediator moves to spec version of A1-AP
    • Need to verify current implementation are fully spec compliant
    • Working on Pairwise test - will be ready as A1-Mediator implementation continues (few weeks)
      • Received info on how to start A1-Mediator in standalone mode - easier to test.

SIM (Alex Stancu)

• Looking at TIM dataset
  
  • Difficult to see how useful the is the data as currently presented & lack of metadata. Very old - 2013.
  • Very large. Looking for somewhere to share it

OAM (Martin Skorupski)

• Carrying on
  • Still work on PM Streaming. See below.

OSC Integration / INT (James Li)

• Discussion with Taiwan lab team at last weeks RSAC
  • 2024 RSAC Meetings 
  • Discussion on how SMO can be deployed, and what are the deployment options available (e.g. charts in it/dep) louis li & bimo fransiscus asisi 
    • https://wiki.o-ran-sc.org/download/attachments/3604609/20230920-ONAP-based%20SMO%20Deployment%20with%20Argo%20CD%20-%20NYCU.pptx?api=v2 
    • ArgoCD seems a good choice - based on findings in ONAP. Would be good to share learnings across OSC/ONAP.
    • Need to ensure charts in it/dep are up to date.

O-DU Vidhu)

• No update this week

SMO (Seshu Kumar Mudiganti)

• No update this week.
• Meeting notes Meeting notes

RSAC (David Kinsey [AT&T] Rittwik Jana)

• No update this week
• Minutes: 2024 RSAC Meetings 

AI/ML platform project (Joseph Thaliath)

• Minutes & Meeting: Meeting notes

• Calendar: https://lists.o-ran-sc.org/g/main/calendar

• No update this week

PM Streaming (Martin Skorupski)

• PM Streaming(Martin Skorupski Alex Stancu John Keeney (Ericsson EST))
  
  • Some updates to the UML sequence diagram
    
    • Source: https://gerrit.o-ran-sc.org/r/gitweb?p=oam.git;a=tree;f=spec/pm-streaming & https://gerrit.o-ran-sc.org/r/q/topic:OAM-349 
    • Still work in progress. Please edit and add a review.
    • Hoping to make progress in coming weeks.
  • OAM-349 - Getting issue details... STATUS

ONAP Update (N.K. Shankaranarayanan)

• No update this week

ONAP/OSC Usecases (N.K. Shankaranarayanan)

• Details of using CPS is still ongoing
  
  • Quite complex ...
    • How to interact/integrate SDNR & CPS, e.g. mounted netconf device models, CM notifications
    • VES vs Netconf id mapping is very tricky & must be maintained.

Disaggregated SMO Flows (N.K. Shankaranarayanan)

• Mapping work in O-RAN WG1 (Disaggregated SMO) to related opensource projects 
  • Strawman for architecture - driven by some candidate usecase flows.
  • Aim for alignment across projects and across diff specs.
  • Aim for common vocabulary etc.
• N.K. Shankaranarayanan working on slides now. See draft slides from last week: 
  • https://lf-o-ran-sc.atlassian.net/wiki/download/attachments/15077441/dec_smo_flows_v0_20230919-1.pptx?version=1&modificationDate=1695137906171&api=v2 
  • Some updates this week:
    

Questions / Comments / AOB:

• None this week.

Meeting ends 45 min.